Project Launch Event
The Centre for Banking Research (CBR) at the Business School (formerly Cass) today launches the CBR Conduct Costs Project, which examines the causes, extent and costs of misconduct for 20 of the world’s leading banks.
Leadership of the project, started in 2012 at the LSE and from 2014 at the CCP Research Foundation, was transferred to CBR last year. The project, co-funded by Euro-Mediterranean Economists Association (EMEA), aims to promote transparency in financial activity, bench-marking the level of conduct costs and conduct risk as an analytical tool for banks and their stakeholders.
The Project also provides valuable insight into banks’ culture, conduct, competence, and regulatory risks.
Drawing on data collected from twenty of the world’s largest banks between January 2008 and December 2018, the latest report reveals the total cost of bank misconduct to individual banks, geographical regions and the industry as a whole as a result of misdemeanours such as mis-selling, money-laundering and market abuse.
Key findings from the latest report include:
- Between them, the 20 banks have paid conduct costs in excess of £377 billion during the data collection period. This includes everything from fines, judgements, and settlements against the bank, to disgorgement of profits, costs of repurchasing securities at par and private actions that relate to misconduct.
- US banks incurred £202.5 billion – approximately 55 per cent – of these costs. UK banks paid £86.09 billion, more than twice that of Euro Area banks (£41.31 billion) and Swiss banks (40.19 billion).
- Nearly 60 per cent of the £377 billion total was attributed to regulatory directed redress, with banks spending to repair previous discretions or better comply with regulations.
- Conduct costs were most commonly occurred through corporate integrity-related regulatory breaches – conduct that undermines trust in the bank – or corporate conduct failings.
Professor Barbara Casu, Director of the Centre for Banking Research and Professor of Finance at the Business School (formerly Cass), said:
“Banks are at the forefront of the global economy and society, so it is important that they engage positively in ethical and legal practice.
“The Conduct Costs project seeks to use historical data to reveal industry shortcomings and provides a framework for good practice across the banking sector.
“We are delighted to reveal our latest insights and look forward to developing further datasets.
“Our main focus in the near future will be on European banks, and we hope this acts as a blueprint for helping banks reduce costs, improve transparency and inspire greater stakeholder confidence.”
Rym Ayadi, President of EMEA and Honorary Visiting Professor at the Business School (formerly Cass), said:
“The report seeks to provide stakeholders with a greater lens into a bank’s culture, conduct, competence and regulatory risk.
“As we look to be entering another period of political and economic instability, banks will increasingly come under the spotlight again – as they were in 2008. It is vital that the sector maintains a level of compliance and stakeholder trust throughout periods of uncertainty.
“The CBR Conduct Costs Project identifies where banks are falling foul of regulation, and in doing so can help reduce the risk – and costs associated – of failure to comply with standards.”
Read the full CBR Conduct Costs Project report [link to be inserted].
Monitoring Misconduct: Maintaining and Developing Banking Standards
José Manuel Campa delivers keynote speech to mark launch of Conduct Costs Project
José Manuel Campa, Chairperson of the European Banking Authority (EBA) delivered a keynote lecture exploring how banking compliance could be monitored and improved.
Mr Campa addressed an online audience at the ‘Monitoring Misconduct: Maintaining and Developing Banking Standards’ event, which took place on the same day that the Centre for Banking Research launched its Conduct Costs Project.
Mr Campa spoke about the role of the EBA in creating a culture of transparency, trust and accountability, with emphasis on those in senior management roles to lead by example.
“Misconduct and subsequent financial penalties threaten to heavily undermine trust in banking systems,” Mr Campa said.
“Investors and stakeholders should always benefit from the highest ethical and legal standards.
“A lot of work has been done in the last decade to adjust risk culture and limit cases of misconduct, but there is still plenty of room for improvement in governance.
“The Centre for Banking Research’s Conduct Costs Project will further help us identify areas that need addressing and develop our blueprint for industry compliance.”
Mr Campa then answered questions from the panel and audience on topics ranging from the importance of gender diversity in controlling misconduct, to the rise of Environmental, Social and Corporate Governance (ESG)-friendly banking and complexity of EBA guidelines.
Professor Barbara Casu, Director of the Centre for Banking Research and Professor of Finance at the Business School (formerly Cass) introduced the report during the event, and said that the project’s findings would support bodies like the EBA to enforce and encourage change.
““Banks play such an important role in shaping society as well as the global economy,” Professor Casu said.
“Any misconduct therefore has far-reaching ramifications beyond its shareholders. The Conduct Costs Project highlights areas of weakness in banking compliance across Europe, to better inform the sector of where it is failing and how it can take steps to reduce financial penalties and other associated costs that arise through misconduct.
“It was excellent to hear Mr Campa speak and endorse the work that we do in the Centre for Banking Research. We look forward to developing our strong ties with the European Banking Authority further as we grow the Conduct Costs Project.”
Watch a full video playback of the ‘Monitoring Misconduct: Maintaining and Developing Banking Standards’ event.
Read more about the Conduct Costs Project.